Ice Patch Archaeology
In 2007, archaeologist Dr. Craig Lee was surveying a patch of ice near Yellowstone National Park when he noticed what looked like a small branch poking through the snow. The branch turned out to be the foreshaft of an ancient hunting weapon, an atlatl dart or throwing spear, carved from a birch sapling more than 10,000 years ago and the oldest organic artifact ever to be recovered from an ice patch. On closer inspection, Lee noticed three evenly spaced notches on either side of the weapon. “Those markings were probably made by the hunter to indicate ownership,” says Lee, a scientist with the Institute of Arctic and Alpine Research in Boulder, Colorado and Montana State University. “The hunter expected to get his weapon back.”
Rarely are organic artifacts like the foreshaft preserved long enough for archaeologists to find them, but the frozen environment of ice patches has held them in a state of suspended animation for hundreds or even thousands of years — that is until, the ice began to melt. As the climate warms, once perennial patches of snow and ice in Montana’s alpine country are melting faster than ever before, yielding artifacts made of wood, leather, and plant fibers that have lain frozen beneath the surface for thousands of years. The melting ice patches and the artifacts they are revealing have given rise to the emerging field of ice patch archaeology.
Like glaciers, ice patches are areas of perennially frozen ice and snow. But because ice patches are small, they don’t move under their own weight as glaciers do. Instead, ice patches accumulate layers of snow and ice over centuries or longer which makes the ice at their cores as old as the ice patch itself. The older and more stable ice contained within ice patches preserves artifacts from long ago that would otherwise be crushed under the shifting weight of glaciers.
But how did the foreshaft that Lee recovered come to be buried in ice in the first place? Lee says that ice patches were attractive to Native Americans in part because the ice patches attracted the animals they hunted. Bison, bighorn sheep, elk, and deer may have used ice patches as sources of water, to cool off, or even to escape biting insects as lower elevation areas became warmer and drier throughout the summer. Although many of the artifacts recovered from Montana’s ice patches have to do with hunting, people also used alpine areas for travel, to escape the summer heat, or for gathering plants, says Lee.
In one ice patch, Lee recovered a piece of plaited leather more than 1500-years-old. The leather was partially covered with the bark of a chokecherry tree, which was used for ornamentation by Native Americans. Some of the artifacts recovered from ice patches are much younger. At one site north of Yellowstone, Lee recovered part of a wooden shaft about four inches long. This weapon fragment was left behind just before Lewis and Clark embarked on their quest to find a waterway to the Pacific Ocean — a journey during which they write of their many encounters with Native Americans.
Lee’s findings are something of a miracle requiring as much luck as it does hard work. It is part of a story whose first chapter begins with a long ago hunter or traveler who perhaps loses an arrow while hunting a bighorn sheep standing on an ice patch. Thousands of years later, Lee visits the ice patch at just the right time of year, when the snow conditions expose the artifact, but not so much that it is left unprotected. If the ice patch melts too fast or before an archaeologist can survey it, the arrow will decompose and be lost forever.
“We don’t really understand how long it takes for these artifacts to decompose once they melt out from the ice, ” says Lee, “but it is only a matter of years and the longer these artifacts lay exposed to the sun and wind, the less we can learn from them.” Because of warming temperatures, a great many artifacts may have already been lost.
Perhaps nowhere is climate change more evident than in Glacier National Park. In 1910, there were as many as 150 glaciers and today there are only 26. Dr. Robert Kelly, a professor of archaeology at the University of Wyoming, and Lee recently finished a three-year project surveying 46 of Glacier’s ice patches.
We may not think of Glacier’s rugged mountains as inhabitable, but humans have had a deep connection with high elevation areas in Glacier for thousands of years. Glacier’s mountains are important vision questing sites and home to powerful Blackfeet spirits like Wind Maker, Cold Maker, Thunder, and Snow Shrinker (Chinook winds). Chief Mountain holds particular significance to Native Americans whose ancestral lands included the Park.
The study was a unique collaboration between university researchers, Glacier National Park, the Blackfeet Nation and the Confederated Salish and Kootenai tribes. Tribal members helped survey ice patches and provided important information on place names, oral histories, trail routes, and traditional use of sub-alpine and alpine areas in the park.
Although no human-made artifacts have been found in Glacier so far, the remnants of trees in some ice patches that are above modern timberline point to a climate that was once warmer than it is today. “During warmer periods of prehistory, some Native American groups may have increased their activities in the mountains, escaping the hot, arid conditions on the plains,” says Rachel Reckin, a University of Cambridge Gates scholar researching how humans adapted to living in the mountains of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem.
Although the climate has shifted in the past, the pace and magnitude of climate change today is unmatched in time which means organic artifacts are melting out of ice patches all over the world. Archaeologists have recovered leather pouches and shoes, a wooden knife handle, baskets, and darts in Switzerland, Norway, Sweden, Canada, and Alaska. In the Northwest Territories, a piece of sinew had archaeologists perplexed until a member of the Shu´htagot’ine Tribe recognized it as part of a ground squirrel snare.
And of course you might remember Ötzi — the 1991 discovery of a more than 5,000 year old man preserved in the Italian Alps. Ötzi was probably a shepherd who appeared to be on the run when he was murdered, and then buried by snow and ice only to be found by a pair of hikers millennia later. Ötzi was so well preserved that researchers were able to determine his last meal — bits of red deer meat and a handful of cereal grains.
Recovering organic artifacts like these have given archaeologists a rare glimpse into the past where the archaeological record is usually dominated by stone and bone. These findings have also been important in preserving Native culture and heritage. But the field of ice patch archaeology is an urgent one. Montana’s ice patches continue to melt and some have disappeared completely. Despite the urgency, only a fraction of ice patches in Montana have been surveyed. The terrain is challenging, the field season is short, and funding is perennially low, says Lee. “It’s a race with an uncertain finish line.”
This article was published in Distinctly Montana Magazine (www.distinctlymontana.com).
Ice Patch Archaeology. Distinctly Montana. Winter 2015.
Watching the Wanderer. Montana Quarterly. Fall 2015.
Tracking Wildlife with Jim Halfpenny. Montana Pioneer. February 2015.
Bird Man: Renowned Wildlife Biologist, Al Harmata. Outside Bozeman. Spring 2015.
Old Man Coyote. Montana Pioneer. December 2014.
Wilderness Man: The Story of Joe Gutkoski. Outside Bozeman. Fall 2014.
Bringing the Bighorns Back. Montana Pioneer. September 2014 (coming soon)
Conrad Anker Meets Challenges Near and Far. Montana Pioneer. May 2014
Wildlife Wingman: Pilot Roger Stradley Tracks from the Air. Outside Bozeman. Spring 2014
Baril, L. M., D. B. Haines, and D. W. Smith. In press. Autumn Raptor Migration in Yellowstone National Park, 2011-2015. Canadian Field Naturalist.
Koel, T. M., J. Arnold, L. Baril, K. Gunther, D. W. Smith, J. Syslo, L. M. Tronstad. 2017. Non-native Lake Trout Induce Cascading Changes in the Yellowstone Lake. Yellowstone Science 25 (1): 42-50.
Bergum, D., K. Gunther, and L. Baril. 2016. Birds and Mammals that Consume Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout in Yellowstone Lake and its Tributaries. Yellowstone Science 24 (2): 85-88.
Baril, L., D. B. Haines, and D. W. Smith, and R. J. Oakleaf. 2014. Long-term Reproduction (1984-2013), Nestling Diet, and Eggshell Thickness of Peregrine Falcons (Falco peregrinus) in Yellowstone National Park. Journal of Raptor Research 49 (4): 347-358.
Baril, L. M., D. B. Haines, K. Duffy, and D. Smith. 2013. The Yellowstone Raptor Initiative. Yellowstone Science 21 (1): 23-32.
Baril, L. M., A. J. Hansen, R. Renkin and R. Lawrence. 2009. Willow-bird Relationships on the Northern Range. Yellowstone Science 17(3): 19-26.
Baril, L. M., D. W. Smith, T. Drummer and T. Koel. 2013. Implications of Cutthroat Trout Declines for Breeding Ospreys and Bald Eagles at Yellowstone Lake. Journal of Raptor Research 47: 234-245.
Baril, L. M., A. J. Hansen, R. Renkin and R. Lawrence. 2011. Songbird Response to Increased Willow (Salix spp.)
Growth in Yellowstone's Northern Range. Ecological Applications 21: 2283-2296.